Análisis de la acción extraordinaria de protección 0731-10-EP presentada por el Señor Olivo Pallo en contra de las autoridades de la comunidad indígena de la Cocha
Fecha
2018-01
Título de la revista
ISSN de la revista
Título del volumen
Editor
Universidad de Guayaquil Facultad de Jurisprudencia Ciencias Sociales y Políticas
Resumen
La Acción Extraordinaria de Protección presentada por el Señor Víctor Manuel Olivo Pallo en contra de aquellas decisiones tomadas por las autoridades indígenas sobre la muerte de su familiar en la comunidad de La Cocha fue objeto de un debate muy amplio por los juristas en el Ecuador. La motivación de la solicitud trata sobre la falta de ejecución de las decisiones adoptadas a fecha 16 y 23 de mayo del 2010 por parte las autoridades del pueblo de Panzaleo, de la nacionalidad kichwa, de la provincia de Cotopaxi, con relación al asesinato de Marco Antonio Olivo Pallo. Es decir que aquellas decisiones no se han ejecutaron nunca debido a la intervención de las autoridades de la justicia ordinaria. Posteriormente la Corte Constitucional en ejercicio de su competencia toma conocimiento de la acción extraordinaria de protección identificando como principales problemas jurídicos si las decisiones fueron tomadas aplicando procedimientos propios respetando los derechos humanos y si las autoridades ordinarias respetaron las decisiones de las comunidades.
En el presente trabajo investigativo analizaremos dicha acción Extraordinaria de Protección, e identificaremos el precedente que indica la limitación al actuar de las autoridades indígenas cuan el bien jurídico protegido vida ha sido vulnerado, estableciendo una propuesta para solucionar la problemática existente.
The Extraordinary Protection Action presented by Mr. Víctor Manuel Olivo Pallo against those decisions taken by the indigenous authorities on the death of his relative in the community of La Cocha was the object of a very broad debate by jurists in Ecuador. The motivation of the request deals with the lack of execution of the decisions adopted on May 16 and 23, 2010 by the authorities of the town of Panzaleo, of the Kichwa nationality, of the province of Cotopaxi, in relation to the murder of Marco Antonio Olivo Pallo. That is to say that those decisions have never been executed due to the intervention of the authorities of the ordinary justice. Subsequently the Constitutional Court in exercise of its jurisdiction becomes aware of the extraordinary protection action identifying as main legal problems if the decisions were taken applying their own procedures respecting human rights and if the ordinary authorities respected the decisions of the communities. In the present investigative work we will analyze this Extraordinary Protection action, and we will identify the precedent that indicates the limitation to the actions of the indigenous authorities when the legally protected life has been violated, establishing a proposal to solve the existing problem.
The Extraordinary Protection Action presented by Mr. Víctor Manuel Olivo Pallo against those decisions taken by the indigenous authorities on the death of his relative in the community of La Cocha was the object of a very broad debate by jurists in Ecuador. The motivation of the request deals with the lack of execution of the decisions adopted on May 16 and 23, 2010 by the authorities of the town of Panzaleo, of the Kichwa nationality, of the province of Cotopaxi, in relation to the murder of Marco Antonio Olivo Pallo. That is to say that those decisions have never been executed due to the intervention of the authorities of the ordinary justice. Subsequently the Constitutional Court in exercise of its jurisdiction becomes aware of the extraordinary protection action identifying as main legal problems if the decisions were taken applying their own procedures respecting human rights and if the ordinary authorities respected the decisions of the communities. In the present investigative work we will analyze this Extraordinary Protection action, and we will identify the precedent that indicates the limitation to the actions of the indigenous authorities when the legally protected life has been violated, establishing a proposal to solve the existing problem.
Descripción
Palabras clave
ACCIÓN EXTRAORDINARIA DE PROTECCIÓN, COMPETENCIA,